Download e-book for iPad: A Defense of Hume on Miracles (Princeton Monographs in by Robert J. Fogelin

By Robert J. Fogelin

ISBN-10: 1400825776

ISBN-13: 9781400825776

Considering the fact that its ebook within the mid-eighteenth century, Hume's dialogue of miracles has been the objective of serious and infrequently ill-tempered assaults. during this ebook, certainly one of our prime historians of philosophy bargains a scientific reaction to those attacks.

Arguing that those criticisms have--from the very start--rested on misreadings, Robert Fogelin starts off by way of delivering a story of how Hume's argument truly unfolds. What Hume's critics (and even a few of his defenders) have didn't see is that Hume's basic argument will depend on solving the right criteria of comparing testimony offered on behalf of a miracle. Given the definition of a miracle, Hume really kind of argues that the criteria for comparing such testimony needs to be tremendous excessive. Hume then argues that, in truth, no testimony on behalf of a spiritual miracle has even come with reference to assembly the suitable criteria for attractiveness. Fogelin illustrates that Hume's critics have constantly misunderstood the constitution of this argument--and have saddled Hume with completely lousy arguments now not present in the textual content. He responds first to a few early critics of Hume's argument after which to 2 contemporary critics, David Johnson and John Earman. Fogelin's objective, despite the fact that, isn't really to "bash the bashers," yet quite to teach that Hume's therapy of miracles has a coherence, intensity, and gear that makes it nonetheless the simplest paintings at the topic.

Show description

Read Online or Download A Defense of Hume on Miracles (Princeton Monographs in Philosophy) PDF

Best theology books

Read e-book online Schleiermacher: A Guide for the Perplexed (Guides for the PDF

Friedrich Daniel Ernst Schleiermacher stands within the first actual rank of Christian systematic theologians with Thomas Aquinas, John Calvin, and Karl Barth and has been dubbed because the 'Father of contemporary Theology'. the start of the period of liberal theology that ruled Protestant concept a minimum of until eventually the 1st international battle is often dated to the book of Schleiermacher's On faith: Speeches to Its Cultured Despisers in 1799.

New PDF release: Specters of Paul: Sexual Difference in Early Christian

The 1st Christians operated with a hierarchical version of sexual distinction universal to the traditional Mediterranean, with girls thought of to be lesser models of fellows. but sexual distinction was once now not thoroughly reliable as a conceptual type around the spectrum of formative Christian considering. particularly, early Christians stumbled on how you can workout theological creativity and to imagine in a different way from each other as they probed the enigma of sexually differentiated our bodies.

Robert Hewitt Brown's Stellar Theology and Masonic Astronomy PDF

The most concise and on element books approximately astrology, numerology, esoteric sciences etc. Profusely illustrated loads so the illiterate and semi literate can nonetheless take advantage of it's lighting and rights. The Freemasonic purist would receive advantages the main from this excellent paintings, yet a complete beginner might additionally develop into extra enlightened.

New PDF release: Can God Be Trusted?: Faith and the Challenge of Evil

In a global riddled with sadness, malice, and tragedy, what motive will we have for believing in a benevolent God? If God is omnipotent and all-loving, why is there loads evil on the earth? John Stackhouse takes a traditionally expert method of this challenge, studying what philosophers and theologians have stated at the topic and providing reassuring solutions for considerate readers.

Extra resources for A Defense of Hume on Miracles (Princeton Monographs in Philosophy)

Sample text

Gross misreadings of this kind almost always carry with them a wholly unfounded criticism, namely, that Hume’s argument is circular—perhaps transparently or risibly so. It is, however, possible to develop criticisms of Hume’s arguments that do not depend on such gross misreadings. A more subtle strategy involves arguing that Hume’s treatment of miracles rests on presuppositions or commitments that are themselves unacceptable. This maneuver can include a dismissal of the shallow criticisms of Hume that have been produced by the gross misreaders.

We are involved in assessing the credentials of testimony in behalf of a type of event that runs deeply counter to common experience. 38 CHAPTER TWO No assumption is made to the effect that the supposed witnesses did not have the experience they reported having, so no question is begged. I have said this already, but it seems worth repeating in response to an egregious (and more than a little haughty) offender. To backtrack. ” Here the word “apparently” may sound cautious, perhaps even generous.

It is not simply that Hume’s essay does not achieve its goals, but that his goals are ambiguous and confused. Most of Hume’s considerations are unoriginal, warmed over versions of arguments that are TWO RECENT CRITICS 41 found in the writings of predecessors and contemporaries. And the parts of “Of Miracles” that set Hume apart do not stand up to scrutiny. Worse still, the essay reveals the weakness and the poverty of Hume’s own account of induction and probabilistic reasoning. And to cap it all off, the essay represents the kind of overreaching that gives philosophy a bad name.

Download PDF sample

A Defense of Hume on Miracles (Princeton Monographs in Philosophy) by Robert J. Fogelin


by Kevin
4.2

Rated 4.95 of 5 – based on 35 votes